Franchising is a favored strategy for businesses aiming to extend their reach and enhance their profitability, particularly in vibrant markets such as Puerto Rico. Known for its dynamic business landscape, Puerto Rico offers productive ground for franchises and franchising, making it an attractive option for companies looking to capitalize on the established reputations and operational models of successful businesses.
In the context of Franchise Puerto Rico, the process involves an original business owner granting a franchise in Puerto Rico to an individual or entity, empowering them to operate under the business’s banner directly as an individual, as an area developer or as a master licensee. This allows the franchisee to leverage the brand’s name, products, and services in the Puerto Rican market, in exchange for a royalty fee to the franchisor. Such a model not only facilitates business expansion with minimal investment but also positions the franchisor to reap the benefits of their franchisees’ successes across Puerto Rico. Embracing franchising in Puerto Rico can thus serve as a catalyst for growth, enabling both local and international businesses to flourish within this dynamic market.
The definition of a franchise varies depending on the law and the context in which it is evaluated, as there is no one concept of a franchise agreement that is universally accepted. The term is used to describe a wide variety of commercial relationships. Federal and state governments all have their own definitions, which generally differ, and may even depend on the type of business. So, when we talk about franchising in Puerto Rico, we’re looking at a regulation or law, a business model, and/or one or more legal documents, including the franchise agreement. Typically the franchisor grants a franchisee permission to use their trademark, business model, and/or other resources to operate a business in Puerto Rico. It also provides the franchisee with a range of materials, such as a business plan, marketing materials, and operations manuals, as well as ongoing support. In exchange, the franchisee pays a fee to the franchisor, often in the form of royalties. The franchisor also typically requires the franchisee to follow certain rules and regulations, such as those related to product and service quality, to protect their brand. The franchise agreement is a legally binding document that outlines the rights and obligations of both the franchisor and the franchisee in the context of Puerto Rican franchising.
Franchisee contracts are one of many types of arrangements used to achieve shared objectives. Distribution & Concession, representation, agency, supply, and general licensing agreements all serve to market products and services, but each approach is different. Agents and sales representatives act on behalf of what the principal has to offer. A licensing agreement can take many forms, based on the industry, but it is mainly centered around the brand being licensed. Distributors are more self-governing and collaborate with different suppliers, typically not linking to a particular brand being provided (unless they are granted permission to do so). The distributor is in the business of distributing, of goods from different brands and the supplier is focused on supplying the goods. While distribution may be part of a franchise organization (supplier-dealer), the most common and wide-spread form of a franchise is the concept known as ‘business format franchise’. A franchisor creates a specific commercial process (the “commercial format”), either for the distribution of goods or the provision of services, and then grants the use of it to the franchisees. Most rules and regulations pay attention to commercial format franchises in the context of Puerto Rico franchising.
To craft a commercial format, the franchise agreement must combine these components into one contract and here lies the complicated task of unifying an integrated network of independent entrepreneurs following an overarching mutual goal. Nevertheless, franchises structures differ. Here are the most typical ones.
The Franchisor sells a franchise directly to the franchisee. The franchisor gains income from the franchisee who pays an initial fee and subsequent regular royalties from total income. While this allows the franchisor to have greater control over how the market grows by directly picking the operators of the unit, it is a slower process as an agreement must be signed for each franchisee. Most franchise laws and regulations concentrate on direct franchising, especially in the Puerto Rican market.
This structure allows someone to be appointed the “master franchisee” of a certain area and be given the right to resell the business in the allocated area. The master franchisee is the one who sells individual units and keeps an eye on them in the marked region. The franchisor makes money from the cost paid by the master franchisee for the license. They also get a portion of franchise fees and royalties from the units sold by the master franchisee. Generally, a development program is organized that requires the licensee to sell a specific number of franchise units within a certain amount of time. Even though it is a quicker way to expand the market, the Franchisor has to share their profits and control of the operations, which is a significant consideration for franchising in Puerto Rico.
The Area Development structure provides a single franchisee the right to offer and sell individual units in a designated territory. This is different from sub-franchising. Under this structure, the franchisor is responsible for the daily operations of the units and keeps an eye on them, which is a crucial aspect of franchising in Puerto Rico.
The Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) regulates franchises through the Franchise Rule. The FTC has its own definition of a franchise and excludes certain businesses and industries. Its definition is extensive, technical and beyond the scope and focus of this article. The purpose of the Franchise Rule is not to regulate the contractual terms of the franchise relationship, but rather to provide franchisees with specific information that the FTC deems necessary to enable a prospective franchisee to make an informed investment decision prior to purchasing a franchise. Neither are franchisors required to file the information with the FTC once completed. FTC regulations do not occupy substantive aspects of state law except where the law is inconsistent with provisions that offer franchisees equal or greater protection. The Rule itself contains many detailed guidelines that require franchisors to provide prospective franchisees prior to the sale including specific information about the franchisor. This information is collected and presented to the prospect in the form of a Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) organized 23 different categories.
In Puerto Rico, there is no specific franchise law. The nature and extent of franchises agreements have been largely developed by the courts. Franchise contracts “are characterized by the granting of independent entrepreneurs the privilege of distributing products of certain brands or of lending names.” Tastee Freez v. Negdo. Seg. Employment, 108 D.P.R. 495, (1979). Apart from caselaw drafters of agreements must consider, Law 75 regulates the termination of distribution contracts, general contract law and specific contracts typified by the Puerto Rico civil Code that have similarities to the franchise structure.
Regardless of the varying legal classifications, there are common elements that are present in most franchises that comprise the rights and obligations that the franchisee acquires from the franchisor through contracts. They are typically reduced to five: (i) the right to offer and sell a product or service; (ii) the right to use the identification and brand related to these services and products; (iii) the right to receive certain assistance and technical support; (iv) the obligation to comply with certain operational rules; and (v) the obligation to pay a fee for those rights. Besides the task of structuring these components in a single agreement, they must comply with regulations applicable to the industry, laws governing trade secrets, trademarks, copyrights and depending on the complexity of the operation, issues such as bonds, security interests, loans, lease contracts, antitrust, supply contracts, non-competition, and numerous pre-agreements with other merchants. Typical issues include the following: Adhesion Contracts, Disproportionate Equity Advantage, Trademark registration, Trademark use rights, Termination of the contractual relationship, Renewal of the franchise, Territory granted if any, Operational obligations, Royalties and other costs, Accounting and auditing responsibility, Equipment, supplies, suppliers, Training, Intellectual property, Business secrets, No competition, Advertising, Insurance, Liability waivers, Assignment of the contract, Applicable law and forum, and Mediation and/or arbitration.
In conclusion, navigating the franchising landscape in Puerto Rico requires a nuanced understanding of both local and global franchising dynamics. Whether you’re exploring opportunities for franchises, looking to delve into franchising in Puerto Rico, or aiming to establish a robust franchise in Puerto Rico, the complexity of drafting operational agreements, franchise master licenses, and navigating conflicts within the franchise chain demands expert legal guidance. As a seasoned attorney with extensive experience in franchising and a deep understanding of the specific challenges and opportunities within Puerto Rico, I am well-positioned to provide comprehensive legal support. From the initial steps of establishing a franchise in Puerto Rico to managing intricate franchising relationships and ensuring compliance with both local and international franchising standards, my expertise covers all aspects of franchising. If you’re seeking to capitalize on the franchising opportunities in Puerto Rico, or require adept legal assistance in managing your franchise operations, I invite you to connect. Together, we can ensure that your franchising venture in Puerto Rico is built on a solid legal foundation, poised for success and growth in this vibrant market.
For a more concise analysis of franchising laws in Puerto Rico. You can obtain copy of my legal journal from the University of Puerto Rico Business Law Journal Vol XV here
The Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) regulates franchises through the Franchise Rule[1]. The FTC has its own definition of a franchise and excludes certain businesses and industries. Its definition is extensive, technical and beyond the scope and focus of this article. The purpose of the Franchise Rule is not to regulate the contractual terms of the franchise relationship, but rather to provide franchisees with specific information that the FTC deems necessary to enable a prospective franchisee to make an informed investment decision prior to purchasing a franchise.[2]ual or greater protection.
The Rule itself contains many detailed guidelines that require franchisors to provide prospective franchisees prior to the sale including specific information about the franchisor.
Form of a Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) organized 23 different categories.
[1] 16 CFR Part 436.
[2] 43 Fed. Reg. 59,614 (December 21, 1978).
Copyright(c). You cannot copy content of this page.